Leave Confederate Statues Alone

(March 3, 2019) In 1965 Texas novelist William Humphrey wrote:

If the Civil War is more alive to the Southerner than the Northerner it is because all of the past is, and this is so because the Southerner has a sense of having been present there himself in the person of one or more of his ancestors. The war filled merely a chapter in his . . . [family history] . . .  transmitted orally from father to son [as] the proverbs, prophecies, legends, laws, traditions-of-origin and tales-of-wanderings of his own tribe. . . It is this feeling of identity with the dead (who are past) which characterizes and explains the Southerner.

It is with kin, not causes, that the Southerner is linked. Confederate Great-grandfather . . . is not remembered for his (probably undistinguished) part in the Battle of Bull Run; rather Bull Run is remembered because Great-grandfather was there. For the Southerner the Civil War is in the family.

Clannishness was, and is, the key to his temperament, and he went off to war to protect not Alabama but only those thirty or forty acres of its sandy hillside, or stiff red clay, which he broke his back tilling, and which was as big a country as his mind could hold.

Statue critics say he fought for slavery. But fewer than 30% of Southern families owned slaves. In truth, according to historian William C. Davis, “The widespread Northern myth that Confederates went to the battlefield to perpetuate slavery is just that, a myth. Their letters and diaries, in the tens of thousands, reveal again and again that they fought because their Southern homeland was invaded. . .”

[Learn more about Civil War & Reconstruction at My Amazon Author Page]

Few today comprehend the magnitude of their sacrifice. About 300,000 Confederate soldiers died when the region’s population was only nine million. If the United States were to suffer proportional casualties in a war today our losses would total 11 million, which would be twenty-six times greater than our dead of World War II.

Given such oblations, the Confederate soldier’s surviving family members wanted to memorialize him. Memorial Day evolved after Federal occupation troops observed Southern women spreading flowers upon the graves of their husbands, sons and brothers during the war. A year after the war the ladies of Columbus, Mississippi strewed flowers on the graves of both the Confederate and Union dead in the town’s Friendship Cemetery. Their gesture started a movement that spread and in the North May 30th became selected as National Memorial Day in 1868.

Since the war had impoverished the South, the Southern ladies could do little more than lay down flowers. There was no money for statues and Union veterans opposed permanent Confederate memorials. But when the sons of Confederate veterans eagerly joined the U.S. Army thirty years later to help win the Spanish-American War, the aging Union Civil War soldiers concluded that their former rivals were also Americans, deserving of memorial recognition.

Carlos Hathcock

Thus, the twenty years from 1898 to 1918 witnessed the installation of 80% of the signature courthouse square Confederate statues still standing in many Southern towns. During that period the typical surviving Confederate soldier aged from 58 years to 78 years. Memorial placements—North and South—surged between 1911 and 1915 because it was the War’s semi-centennial and the old soldiers were fading away.

Today a vocal minority holds Confederate soldiers in contempt, much like the many Americans who sneered at returning Vietnam veterans in the 1960s and 70s. Amid chants of “Hey, hey, LBJ, how many babies did you kill today?” some civilians mocked the soldiers. Today most Americans old enough to remember cringe with shame when recalling such incidents.

As reported in The New York Times, for example, in 1968 a one-armed vet was accosted at a Colorado college.

Pointing to the missing limb another student asked, “Did you get that in Vietnam?”

The veteran said yes.

“Serves you right,” said the student.

It took years, but eventually the public abandoned the ridiculers and gave Vietnam vets their due credit thereby underscoring the maxim: “Whoever marries the spirit of this age will find himself a widower in the next.”

Thus, we should be aware that decisions to tear down century-old monuments put us at risk for future remorse. Dishonoring such monuments demeans later generations of American warriors who were inspired by the courage of the Confederate soldier.

Consider, for example, that post-Civil-War Southerners consistently came to our nation’s defense more readily than did other Americans. Presently, 44% of American military are from the South even though it represents just 36% of the nation’s population.

Tennessee’s Alvin York was America’s most famous infantryman in World War I. Although his grandfather was a Union deserter, two of his grand-uncles sided with the Confederacy.  Texan Audie Murphy was the most decorated soldier of World War II. In Vietnam, an Arkansas sniper named Carlos Hathcock killed more enemy than anyone and even put a bullet in the eye of an opposing sniper through the foe’s telescopic sight. (Steven Spielberg theatrically copied this in his Saving Private Ryan movie.) Each man was born into the grinding poverty that typified much of the South for a century after the Civil War. As boys they hunted game for food, not sport.

During World War II, the first American flag to fly over the captured Japanese fortress at Okinawa was a Confederate Battle Flag. It was put there by a group of marines to honor their company commander—a South Carolinian who suffered a paralyzing wound in the victorious assault. Some of the tank crews that freed prisoners from German concentration camps also flew the Confederate Battle Flag.

The academic community is at the forefront of those wanting to remove Confederate statues, which they characterize as racist. In doing so they violate the American Historical Society’s warning against “presentism,” which is defined as an uncritical tendency to interpret the past in terms of modern values. It fails to recognize that racial attitudes throughout America 150 years ago were different than they are today. That is why Abraham Lincoln said during an 1858 debate, “. . . I am not, nor ever have been, in favor of bringing about in any way the social and political equality of the white and black races. . .”

Finally, toppling Confederate statues has evolved into a mob sport, with impunity for the vandals. Since such conduct requires no more bravery than kicking a puppy, we may wonder what comes next when the pious critics screw-up more courage. Arcata, California has already removed a statue of President McKinley. Notre Dame University has covered a mural that celebrates Christopher Columbus’s discovery voyages. Anti-statue activists are behaving much like the leaders of the former Soviet Union where censorship and rewritten history was part of the state’s effort to ensure that the correct political spin was put on their history. In response, George Orwell warned:

The most effective way to destroy a people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history.

22 thoughts on “Leave Confederate Statues Alone

  1. Pingback: Sins and Virtues of Civil War History | Civil War Chat

  2. Pingback: When Memory Contradicts Academic History | Civil War Chat

  3. Tim Duskin

    C.S. Lewis referred to this as “chronological snobbery.” He pointed this same thing out in his day.

    Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      Yes, it is a common error. It is narcissistic because it implies that today’s attitudes will never be judged as immoral in the future.

      Reply
  4. Michael Hitt

    This article is right on point and well written. Thank You for saying exactly how and what I feel as a true southerner from Georgia.

    Reply
  5. Michael C. Lucas

    The cause of self interest is always in conflict with someone else’s.

    No the general myth that Southern Confederates fought for perpetual slavery is certainly a myth, although their were some who thought twice about those notions.

    On the flip side of Northern Unionists, didn’t fight for actual equality and freedom for everyone either. They were mostly fighting to sustain a homogeneous American society for themselves. That didn’t include Native Americans or African Americans either. Anymore than it did those fellow Anglo-Americans they chose to invade and ruin. Northerners fought for dominance over the nation even if it meant Civil War to attain the dominance.

    Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      Yes, the ancient wisdom that “money makes the world go ’round” is always a factor in wars.

      Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      Yes, Randall. You may publish it. I was pleased to start the post by quoting a Texas author and also latter getting a chance to remind readers that Audie Murphy was a Texan.

      Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      Thanks for the question. I’ve been doing this blog for five years w/o realizing that I had no “Follow Me” button. See it now (Follow Civil War Chat) on the right sidebar of the front page toward the bottom.

      Reply
  6. Edward Murdough

    Good article, but it fails to point out that a large percentage of today’s Southern soldiers are black.

    Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      I do not have current statistics showing the percentage breakdown of military personnel by race for the South, or any other region.

      However, the analysis below—based on data published by The Washington Post—show that residents of the former Confederate states are 42% more likely to join today’s military than members of the twenty slave-free states that fought on the side of the North during the Civil War.

      https://civilwarchat.wordpress.com/2018/11/16/confederate-symbols-correlate-to-american-patriotism/

      Reply
    1. Phil Leigh Post author

      Thanks, Phil.

      Sharing it will help get our message out, since the mainstream media will not print it.

      Reply
  7. Ronald E. Walker

    I could not agree with you more. You have facts that are true. Not the politically correct nonsense going on today. Thank you, Phil.

    Ron Walker

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.