South’s Reparations Already Paid

The following is my “Letter to the Editor” published in this month’s Civil War News. 

As the Sesquicentennial of Reconstruction progresses and the popular press debates whether slavery merits reparations, few students of the era realize that Southerners have already paid a form of reparations, if not for slavery then as a penalty for the war.

As the table below illustrates, for at least twenty-five years after the war three items represented more than half of the federal budget: (1) surpluses to repay federal war debt, (2) interest on federal war debt, and (3) Union veterans pensions. Former Confederates derived no benefit from such items, yet they had to pay their share of federal taxes to fund them. If the Confederacy had been an independent defeated foe such payments would have been reparations.


But the table does not tell the whole story.

First in 1869, four years after the war ended, the Republican-controlled federal government passed a law that required federal debt to be redeemed in gold. But during the war the great majority of investors used paper money, which traded at a discount to gold to buy the bonds. The discount got as high as 63%—meaning that a paper dollar was worth only thirty-seven cents—after General Grant sustained heavy casualties in the 1864 overland campaign only to be stalemated at Petersburg.

In short, gold redemption was a huge windfall for the bondholders. Few, if any, bonds were held by Southerners. Some of the bonds were held by national banks which were required to buy them as monetary reserves under the 1863 National Banking Act, but ordinary Northerners bought most of them during war bond drives. Bond interest also had to be paid in gold which was another windfall to Northerners.

Second, Union veterans pensions did not stop growing until 1921, which was fifty-five years after the war ended. Moreover, the total amount paid as early as 1917 was about twice as much as the combined federal and Northern state governments spent to fight the war. By 1893 Union veterans pensions represented 40% of federal spending and many Union veterans were also given federal sinecures as jobs.


My Civil War Books

The Confederacy at Flood Tide
Lee’s Lost Dispatch and Other Civil War Controversies
Trading With the Enemy
Co. Aytch: Illustrated and Annotated



4 thoughts on “South’s Reparations Already Paid

  1. Barry Lynn Colbaugh

    Weekly Atlanta Intelligencer November 29, 1865

    A special to the Missouri Democrat said that January last that a draft for three thousand pounds sterling, drawn by the Secretary of the rebel Treasury on a banking firm from London, was captured by one of our blockading vessels off the Southern coast and forwarded to the Treasury Department here a few days since. The draft was sent to New York, presented at the counter of American agents of the firm of whom it was drawn and promptly paid in gold

  2. Shara Katayama

    Things happen and can not be repaired with money. Forgiveness of those who harm you is more important than money anyway. All those people are long dead, but it was up to them to do the forgiving.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.